Connecting to City Water: What Happens to the Old Well
Your choices for the old well, and why capping it is not one of them.
When a property moves from a private well to municipal water, most owners think about the new connection and not about the well. Under the South Florida Water Management District rule, a well that has been permanently disconnected from its pumping equipment, and has not been converted to a monitoring well, is an abandoned well. The property owner is responsible for having it plugged by a licensed water well contractor.
That does not mean every old well has to be plugged. It means the well needs a decision: keep it in proper use, or plug it properly. Leaving it disconnected and capped is the one option the rule does not allow.
Why Disconnecting the Pump Changes the Well's Status
The rule ties abandonment to the pump. While the well is connected to pumping equipment and in use, it is a working well. Once the pump is permanently removed or disconnected and nothing replaces it, the well becomes an abandoned well, even if the casing is sound and the water is good.
That is why so many Treasure Coast properties have abandoned wells without the owners knowing. The well was simply switched off when the house went onto city water.
Option One: Keep the Well for Irrigation
Many homeowners on the Treasure Coast keep their old well for the lawn and landscaping and use city water only inside the house. Irrigating from a well instead of from metered city water is a common reason to keep it.
Keeping the well means it stays connected to pumping equipment and in use. It also has to be kept completely separate from the plumbing that city water now serves. Your utility will not allow a private well to be connected to plumbing that is also supplied by public water, because that creates a cross connection that can let well water flow back into the public system. Ask your utility what it requires at connection.
If the well is worth keeping, see irrigation well conversion, and if it has slowed or failed, well rehabilitation may bring it back.
Option Two: Plug the Well
If you will not use the well, it should be plugged by a licensed water well contractor under a permit. Plugging fills the well from the bottom to the top with grout so it no longer connects the surface to the aquifer. It is permanent, and when it is done you receive documentation for your property records.
The steps are set out in how a flow or artesian well is plugged, the price drivers in well abandonment cost in Florida, and the permit in well abandonment permits.
Why Capping Is Not an Option
A cap or a slab closes the top of the casing. It does nothing to the open well underneath, which can still carry surface water, fertilizer or fuel into the aquifer, and allow water to move between layers that are supposed to stay separate. A capped, disconnected well is still an abandoned well under the rule. For the full explanation of what the rule covers, see do I have to plug an abandoned well in Florida.
How to Decide
| If... | Then... |
|---|---|
| The well produces good water and you irrigate | Keeping it for irrigation is often worth considering |
| The well has slowed, produces sand or the casing is old steel | Have it evaluated; rehabilitation may be possible, otherwise plug it |
| You have no use for the well | Plug it properly and keep the documentation |
| The well flows on its own | Treat it as a priority; see MY WELL IS FLOWING ON ITS OWN |
| You plan to sell in the next few years | Decide now; an unresolved well tends to surface in a sale |
What We Do
Brent Pump Works is a licensed water well contractor that has worked on the Treasure Coast since 2004. We can look at the old well, tell you honestly whether it is worth keeping, and either set it up for irrigation or plug it under permit. We handle artesian well abandonment across Martin, St. Lucie and Palm Beach counties.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens to my old well when I connect to city water?
If the pump is disconnected and the well is not put to another approved use, it becomes an abandoned well under the South Florida Water Management District rule. The property owner is then responsible for having it plugged by a licensed water well contractor. Keeping it in proper use for irrigation is the other option.
Can I keep my well for irrigation after switching to city water?
Often, yes. Many Treasure Coast homeowners irrigate from the old well and use city water inside the house. The well must stay connected to pumping equipment and in use, and it must be kept completely separate from the plumbing supplied by city water. Check your utility's requirements at connection.
Can my well stay connected to the house plumbing with city water?
No. Utilities do not allow a private well to be connected to plumbing that public water also supplies, because it creates a cross connection that can contaminate the public system. If you keep the well, it should serve a separate system, such as irrigation, with no connection to the city supply.
Is it enough to just cap the old well?
No. A cap covers the top but leaves the well open underground. Under the rule, a disconnected well that has not been converted to an approved use is abandoned and must be plugged from the bottom to the top with grout by a licensed water well contractor.
Do I need a permit to plug a well after connecting to city water?
Yes. A permit is required before any well is abandoned in Florida, and the work must be done by a licensed water well contractor. Brent Pump Works prepares and submits the application as part of the job, so you do not need to deal with the permitting office.
How do I know whether my old well is worth keeping?
Have it evaluated. A well that produces steady, clean water may be worth keeping for irrigation. One that has slowed, produces sand or has deteriorating steel casing may need rehabilitation or plugging. A camera inspection can show the condition of the casing before you decide.
My well was capped when the house went onto city water years ago. Now what?
It is very likely an abandoned well under the rule and should be plugged. Older capped wells sometimes contain pump parts, pipe or debris that must be removed first. We can locate and assess it, give you a written estimate, and handle the permit.
Does the utility handle the old well when it connects me?
Generally, no. The utility handles the water connection. Responsibility for an abandoned well stays with the property owner, and the plugging has to be done by a licensed water well contractor. Ask the utility what it requires regarding the old well when you schedule your connection.
Decide What Happens to the Old Well
We will look at the well, tell you whether it is worth keeping for irrigation, and if it is not, plug it under permit and give you the documentation.