Well Abandonment or Rehabilitation: Which Is Right?
An honest way to decide whether an old well is worth saving.
Not every old or struggling well needs to be plugged. Some can be brought back with cleaning, screen repair or a PVC liner and give years more service. Others are past saving, and the right answer is to plug them properly and, if water is still needed, drill a new well. Brent Pump Works does all three, which is why we can tell you honestly which one fits your well.
Three Options
| Option | What it is | Best when |
|---|---|---|
| Rehabilitation | Cleaning, screen repair or lining an old well with PVC to restore it | The well is wanted and its structure can be restored |
| Abandonment | Plugging the well permanently from bottom to top with grout, under permit | The well is not needed, or cannot be saved |
| New well | Drilling a replacement well, with the old one plugged | Water is needed and the old well cannot deliver it |
When Rehabilitation Makes Sense
Details are on well rehabilitation.
When Plugging Is the Answer
When a New Well Is Better
If water is needed but the old well cannot deliver it reliably, a new well is often the better long-term investment, drilled to current standards in the right location. The old well is then plugged. See well drilling.
What Rules Out Rehabilitation
How the Costs Compare
Every well is different, so the right comparison is between real estimates for your well. In general terms:
How We Decide
We start by looking at the well: depth, casing, flow, production and condition. Where the inside of the casing matters, a well camera inspection shows it from top to bottom. Then we tell you which option fits and why. If it can be saved, we save it. If it cannot, we plug it correctly.
For the rule on abandoned wells, see do I have to plug an abandoned well in Florida. Brent Pump Works handles artesian well abandonment, rehabilitation and drilling across Martin, St. Lucie and Palm Beach counties, licensed and working on the Treasure Coast since 2004.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an old well be saved instead of plugged?
Often, if the structure can be restored and the well is wanted. Cleaning, screen repair or a PVC liner can bring a slowed or sandy well back into service. If the casing has collapsed, the flow cannot be controlled or the water cannot be used, plugging is the right answer.
What is PVC well lining?
Lining installs a PVC liner inside an old, deteriorating steel casing, restoring a sound barrier inside the well without drilling a new one. It suits wells where the casing is failing in places but the well is otherwise worth keeping. An inspection shows whether lining is possible.
Is it cheaper to fix my well or drill a new one?
Usually rehabilitation costs less, when the well can be saved. If it cannot, a new well is the better investment, and the old well has to be plugged. The honest comparison is between estimates for your specific well after it has been assessed.
How do you decide whether to rehabilitate or plug?
We look at depth, casing condition, flow, production and water quality, and use a camera inspection when the inside of the casing matters. Then we recommend the option that fits. If the well can be saved, we save it; if not, we plug it under permit.
My well slowed down. Does that mean it needs plugging?
Not necessarily. Gradual slowing is often caused by sediment, scale or iron bacteria and can be corrected with cleaning or rehabilitation. A sudden drop, sand production or a failed casing changes the picture. An assessment shows which it is before you decide anything.
Do I have to plug my old well if I drill a new one?
If the old well is no longer used and is disconnected from its pump, it becomes an abandoned well under the rule and should be plugged by a licensed water well contractor. Plugging the old well is a normal part of replacing one.
Can a free-flowing well be rehabilitated?
Sometimes. If the casing is sound and the well is wanted, flow can sometimes be controlled with a proper valve or wellhead. If the casing has failed or the flow cannot be controlled, the well has to be plugged. Flowing wells need assessment before either option is chosen.
Can you do rehabilitation, plugging and drilling yourselves?
Yes. Brent Pump Works is a licensed water well contractor that rehabilitates, plugs and drills wells, and has worked on the Treasure Coast since 2004. Because we do all three, the recommendation is based on what fits your well rather than on which single service we happen to offer.
Not Sure Whether to Save It?
We will look at the well, tell you honestly whether it can be rehabilitated, and give you an estimate for the option that fits.